Tuesday, September 25, 2007

Canadian Military Ghostwriters of Karzai Speech

It is not surprising that Karzai would get advice and even content for his speech from the Canadian military or that the Conservatives would also hope that his speech would shore up support for the mission. Karzai is a creation of the US and its allies. He needs continuing military and development aid. He even hires his guards from a US security corporation or perhaps the US foots the bill. I doubt that the military would write rather than contribute to and vet his speech but you never know..

Canadian military wrote Karzai speech: opposition
Tue Sep 25, 2007 5:18 PM EDT



By David Ljunggren

OTTAWA (Reuters) - A speech that Afghan President Hamid Karzai delivered to Canada's Parliament a year ago, urging the country's continued military support, was nothing more than a "political stunt," written by Canadian defense ministry staff, an opposition party charged on Tuesday.

The Afghan embassy denied the allegation, calling it ludicrous and insulting.

Dawn Black of the left-leaning New Democrats said the speech -- in which Karzai asked Canada to keep its soldiers in Afghanistan -- was a blatant bid by the minority Conservative government to shore up flagging support for the mission.

Canada has 2,500 troops in the southern city of Kandahar. One soldier was killed on Tuesday, the 71st to die since Canada deployed forces to Afghanistan in late 2002.

"President Karzai's address to Parliament was an elaborately staged political stunt by this government to sell Canadians on the combat mission in Kandahar," Black said.

Documents that the New Democrats obtained through access to information legislation showed a team of military officials worked on the speech at the request of Karzai's office.

"Team prepared initial draft of president's address to Parliament 22 Sep(tember). It was noted that key statistics, messages, themes, as well as overall structure, were adopted by the president in his remarks," reported one officer.

The Afghan embassy said the draft had been written by officials in Karzai's office. It added: "To suggest otherwise is not only ludicrous but also verges on being insulting."

In the speech, Karzai said Taliban militants were trying "to frighten us all into the dark ages" and urged Canadians to be patient.

A spokesman for Defence Minister Peter MacKay accused the New Democrats -- who want Canada's troops withdrawn immediately -- of trying to undermine Karzai's integrity.

Polls show Canadians are split over the mission, which is due to end in February 2009. Critics say the military has spent far too much effort on fighting and not enough on development.

Black said military officers were so pleased by the reaction to Karzai's speech that they planned a follow-up tour of Canada by the Afghan development minister.

"The aim of the tour is to capitalize on the recent president's visit and address to Parliament by emphasizing the development work ... and drawing attention away from persistent media reporting of the security situation," read the report.

Black said she would call for an emergency debate in Parliament to consider the matter.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

© Reuters 2007.

No comments: