Lawyer: Cutting house arrest a costly proposition.

Harper does not worry about money if it will buy votes. The point is not that his scheme will be more expensive and no doubt ineffective but that it will garner some votes and please some of his core constituents that may bring in more money to the party. The general taxpayer has to foot the bill but if this helps Harper get elected he could care less.


Cutting house arrest a costly proposition: lawyer
Last Updated: Friday, September 26, 2008 11:11 AM CT
CBC News
The Conservatives' campaign promise to get rid of conditional house arrest sentences for about 30 crimes would be expensive, a group of Manitoba defence lawyers says.
If the Tories are re-elected Oct. 14, leader Stephen Harper says they will end the use of house arrest sentences for property crimes, weapons offences, serious vehicular crimes, as well as drug trafficking, kidnapping and trafficking in people.
But house arrest is for low risk offenders and it saves the government millions of dollars, said Mark Wasyliw, spokesman for the Criminal Trial Lawyers Association.
If the 771 people currently serving conditional house arrest sentences in Manitoba were sent to jail, it would cost the government $110,000 per day or about $40 million a year, Wasyliw said.
Finding room for more prisoners in jails that are already overcrowded would also be a problem, he said.
Low risk offenders also hold jobs, pay taxes, support families and become rehabilitated in the community, he said.
"We're talking about huge sums of money for somebody who works and pays taxes," he said. "You're going to take that tax money out of the system and you're going to have to pay money for welfare for their families."
But Manitoba Conservative candidate Steve Fletcher defends the party's campaign promise, saying the public wants the government to get tougher on criminals.
"I hear this at the door all the time — that people are sick and tired of these revolving doors in the justice system and the hug-a-thug mentality of some of the other politicians," said the incumbent in the Charleswood-St. James Assiniboia riding of Winnipeg.
Harper has said the cost of sending more people to jail would be "small and manageable